top of page

The Do's and Don'ts of Book Cover Design: Common Mistakes to Avoid

Updated: Oct 31

Discover essential tips for creating eye-catching book covers. Learn common design mistakes to avoid and best practices to follow for successful book marketing.

book cover design do's and don'ts
 

The book cover reigns supreme in book marketing. As the gateway to your story, it wields unparalleled power to captivate or repel potential readers.

Your book covers are often the first impression a potential reader will have of your work, and it plays a significant role in their decision to pick up the book or scroll past it. For self-published authors, your book cover is a powerful marketing tool that can make or break your success.

As an experienced graphic designer who has worked extensively with indie authors, I’ve seen common design pitfalls that can derail a book's potential. Let’s walk through the essential do’s and don’ts of book cover design, shedding light on mistakes you should avoid, and best practices to follow.

The Do's and Don'ts of Book Cover Design

1. Do: Know Your Genre Inside and Out

Your book cover needs to speak to its target audience, and that begins with understanding your genre's design norms. Each genre has a set of visual cues that readers subconsciously look for. Romance covers, for example, often feature bright, passionate colors and imagery of the protagonists, while thrillers tend to use darker palettes with suspenseful or eerie visuals.

Why It Matters:

Readers have specific expectations for genre-specific book covers, and if you veer too far from the norm, you might confuse your audience or fail to attract them altogether.

Tip: Spend time analyzing successful books in your genre. Pay attention to trends in color, imagery, and typography. While creativity is encouraged, there’s a fine line between standing out and alienating your potential readers.

2. Don’t: Overcrowd the Design

One of the most common mistakes I see in indie book cover design is trying to cram too much into the space. Authors often want to communicate the entire story arc through the cover, resulting in a chaotic, cluttered design that overwhelms the viewer.

The Risk:

Too much visual information confuses the reader and detracts from the overall impact of the cover. A busy design dilutes the message you're trying to send and can look amateurish.

Tip: Focus on one or two main elements. A single, striking image paired with clean typography can be far more effective than a cover that's trying to do too much. Simplicity often equals sophistication.

3. Do: Choose Fonts Wisely

Typography is often an overlooked aspect of book cover design, but it can make or break the professionalism of your cover. Fonts set the tone of your book and play a crucial role in communicating its genre and mood.

Best Practices:

  • Match your font to your genre: A serif font might work well for historical fiction, while sans-serif fonts can evoke a more modern or minimal feel. Script fonts may suit romance novels but should be avoided in genres like thrillers or sci-fi.

  • Prioritize readability: The title of your book should be legible even at a thumbnail size. Readers often browse through small versions of the cover online, so ensure that both the title and the author’s name are clear and easy to read.

Font Pitfalls to Avoid:

  • Overuse of decorative fonts: While fancy fonts may seem appealing, they often hinder readability, especially if used for both the title and the author’s name.

  • Using too many fonts: Stick to two fonts maximum—one for the title and one for the author’s name or tagline. Too many fonts create a disorganized and unprofessional look.

4. Don’t: Use Low-Quality Images

Nothing screams "amateur" more than a cover with pixelated or blurry images. When designing a cover, always use high-resolution images. Low-quality graphics immediately diminish the overall perception of your book.

The Risks:

A pixelated cover suggests that the same level of care was not applied to the story inside. This can lead potential readers to question the quality of your writing and editing.

Tip: Always opt for images that are at least 300 DPI (dots per inch) for print covers. If you’re using stock images, invest in high-quality, royalty-free options, rather than free images that might not meet the resolution standards.

5. Do: Invest in Professional Design

Many self-published authors are tempted to cut corners on cover design, thinking that a DIY approach will save money. However, cover design is one of the most crucial investments you can make. Hiring a professional designer ensures your cover is not only aesthetically pleasing but also optimized for the market.

Benefits of Hiring a Professional:

  • Market insight: A professional designer who specializes in book covers will understand the market trends and how to create a cover that stands out while adhering to genre norms.

  • Technical expertise: Designers know how to create a cover that will look good in both print and digital formats. They’ll also ensure that the cover meets the specific size and resolution requirements for publishing platforms like Amazon or IngramSpark.

Tip: If hiring a designer isn’t in your budget, consider using platforms like Fiverr or Reedsy to find affordable, skilled designers. Alternatively, many designers offer pre-made covers that are less expensive but still high-quality.

6. Don’t: Ignore the Back Cover and Spine

While the front cover gets most of the attention, don't neglect the spine and back cover. Especially for print books, the spine is often the first thing a reader sees on a bookstore shelf. The back cover is prime real estate for a blurb, author bio, or endorsements.

Common Mistakes:

  • Unreadable spine text: If your book title or author name is too small or cramped on the spine, it can be difficult for readers to spot your book.

  • Back cover overload: Avoid packing too much information onto the back cover. Stick to the essentials—a compelling blurb, some quotes from reviews, and your author photo or bio.

Tip: Ensure the design of the spine and back cover complements the front cover. Consistency is key to creating a cohesive look across all parts of the book.

7. Do: Think About Your Audience’s Preferences

Ultimately, your book cover is for your readers. Take their tastes and preferences into account when designing the cover. A well-researched design can resonate deeply with your target audience and make your book stand out.

Strategies:

  • Consider reader demographics: If your audience is younger, you might want to use brighter colors and bolder typography. If your readers are fans of literary fiction, a more subdued, minimalist approach could work better.

  • Gather feedback: Use social media or author communities to get feedback on your cover options. You can create polls or ask for opinions on platforms like Facebook or Instagram. Reader input is invaluable in crafting a cover that appeals to your audience.

8. Don’t: Follow Trends Blindly

While it's important to be aware of genre norms and market trends, blindly following trends can result in a cover that feels generic or outdated by the time your book is published. What’s popular now might not be in six months.

The Downside:

Trendy covers can lack staying power. They might attract readers in the short term, but your book could look out of place over time among newer releases.

Tip: Instead of following every trend, aim for a design that reflects the timeless essence of your story. Focus on creating a cover that’s visually striking and represents the core themes of your book. This way, your cover will remain relevant even as trends evolve.

9. Do: Ensure Your Cover Looks Good in Multiple Formats

Your cover needs to look appealing in both physical and digital formats. An increasing number of readers are buying ebooks, and the digital version of your cover is just as important as the print version. What looks great on a full-size print cover may not translate well to a thumbnail-sized ebook cover.

Considerations:

  • Test different sizes: Ensure your cover is legible and eye-catching in smaller formats, like ebook thumbnails or mobile previews.

  • Adaptability: The layout and design of your cover should adapt well to different sizes and formats. You might need to adjust the layout for the ebook version so that the main elements remain clear and readable.

Tip: Design for the smallest format first (usually a thumbnail), and then scale up to ensure it works across all mediums. Many designers start by creating a basic concept in a small size before fleshing out the details for print.

10. Don’t: Overcomplicate the Color Scheme

Color plays an essential role in evoking the right mood and attracting readers, but it’s easy to go overboard. Too many contrasting or bright colors can clash, making the cover feel chaotic and unprofessional.

The Risk:

A poorly chosen color scheme can make your cover hard to read, or worse, off-putting to potential readers. Neon green and pink might seem bold, but they’re rarely appropriate unless you're aiming for a very niche market.

Tip: Stick to a limited color palette—two to three complementary colors work best. Use colors that align with the genre (dark blues and blacks for thrillers, soft pastels for romance, etc.). And always ensure your text stands out against the background.

11. Do: Remember That Your Cover Is a Marketing Tool

At its core, your book cover is a sales pitch. It's there to entice, inform, and persuade. It should provide just enough intrigue to make the reader pick up the book but leave them wanting more.

Approach:

Think of your cover as a billboard. It needs to grab attention quickly and convey enough information to make someone pause. The cover should communicate the essence of the story without giving everything away.

Tip: Ask yourself: Does your cover tell potential readers what they need to know at a glance? Will they be able to discern the genre, mood, and tone? If not, it’s time to revisit the design.

12. Don’t: Forget About Branding

Consistency across covers is crucial for authors planning a series or multiple books. Creating a cohesive brand for your books helps readers easily identify your work and builds recognition over time.

Common Mistake:

Inconsistency in typography, color schemes, or design elements across a series can confuse readers and diminish your brand.

Tip: Work with your designer to develop a style guide for your book covers, ensuring consistency in fonts, colors, and layouts. This is especially important if you're releasing a series, as each cover should be distinct but still clearly part of a set.

The Bottom Line: Investing in Your Book's First Impression

Designing a book cover is no easy task, but when done right, it can be one of the most powerful tools in your marketing arsenal. Follow these do's and don'ts to create a cover that grabs readers' attention and makes your book stand out in a competitive market.

Whether you're designing the cover yourself or working with a professional, keep in mind that your book cover is an investment—both in time and resources. Make it count by creating something that not only reflects your story but also resonates with your target audience.

The right cover can open doors, making your book impossible to ignore in the sea of options available to readers. Don't underestimate its power.

 

For more practical tips and guidance on building a thriving author career, download our free branding worksheets or check out our portfolio of author branding projects to see how we’ve helped others create lasting impressions with their readers.

Comments


bottom of page